Voting gimmick cheapens Roberto Clemente Award

JEWISH BASEBALL NEWS –Three cheers for Oakland A’s RP Craig Breslow, whose efforts to raise funding for pediatric cancer research have earned him a nomination for the 2010 Roberto Clemente Award.

It’s an honor simply to have one’s name uttered in the same sentence as Clemente, the Pittsburgh Pirate great who died in 1972 when a plane he chartered to bring aid to earthquake-ravaged Nicaragua crashed.

I’d love to recommend that you cast a vote for Breslow, as MLB rules permit. But I can’t.

It’s not that Breslow — whom Sporting News recently called the smartest man in sports — doesn’t deserve it. It’s that the voting process is more like a marketing gimmick for MLB.com and Chevrolet, the Award’s sponsor.

Click here and you’ll see what I mean. Step 1 is to choose a nominee. Step 2, which is mandatory, is to enter your personal information — name, address, phone, e-mail, time-frame for purchasing or leasing a new vehicle, and three Chevy vehicles you’re most interested in — into a “sweepstakes” form and send it off to MLB.com and Chevy.

I’m no profit prude. Baseball is a business, and the MLB is entitled to squeeze a buck out of it in any way it can. One day I hope to squeeze a few nickels out of it myself. (See Google Ads at the end of this post.)

But to say to fans: “Sure, we’ll let you vote for the most selfless baseball player, but you’ll have to give up your privacy and endure an avalanche of spam as punishment”?

Just doesn’t seem right to me.

— Scott Barancik, Editor/Curmudgeon

(Note to readers: Your comments are welcome below.)

###


Share

Similar Posts

  • |

    How’d they do?

    By Scott Barancik, Editor Major League Baseball’s 2018 Spring Training ended yesterday. So how did the 19 Jews who were invited to play perform? Here are the batting highlights: A total of 12 Jewish position players collectively hit .272 with 12 HRS and 53 RBIs in 372 at-bats. Alex Bregman’s 12 walks tied for #5 among all MLB players. His…

  • POTD: Davis

    JEWISH BASEBALL NEWS —With most minor leagues in playoff mode now, we’re afraid that JBN’s Players of the Day feature will be thinner for a while. As it is, we’re trying not to think about the end of the MLB season. Don’t think about it, don’t think about it… On the bright side, the winter…

  • Braun’s 3 RBIs, and more

    JEWISH BASEBALL NEWS — Here are your Players of the Day for Friday (9/24/2010): Rookie 1B Ike Davis of the New York Mets went 3/4 and scored once in a 3-2 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies. A 9th-inning double was his 32nd two-bagger of the season, second-highest among N.L. rookies. Davis is tied for 3rd…

  • Red Sox’ Kalish faces surgery, again

    Going shopping? Please use our Amazon.com link ———————————————————————— By Scott Barancik/Jewish Baseball News Injury-prone Boston Red Sox outfielder Ryan Kalish has hurt his right (non-throwing) shoulder and will undergo surgery, forcing him to miss Spring Training and probably some of the 2013 regular season. The news comes as a blow to Red Sox fans who hoped the…