By Shel Wallman
(Editor’s note: our original list of the top D-1 players was updated 8/5/2025 to add OF Harrison Feinberg, whom we inadvertently had omitted.)
Welcome to our 2025 College All-America Team, which lists the top performers at every position among Jewish athletes playing Division 1 baseball. The squad includes 8 position players and 8 pitchers. The University of Pittsburgh is the only school with more than one player. Seven of the All-Americans hail from California, while Texas, New York, and New Jersey each claim two.
Two of the 16 College All-Americans were selected in last week’s MLB draft. The Red Sox chose SS Henry Godbout (University of Virginia) in Round #2C (75nd overall). The Guardians picked LHP Ryan Prager (Texas A&M University) in Round #9 (282nd overall).
The player stats shown below reflect both regular-season games and College World Series games.
And now, here are our award winners.
POSITION PLAYERS
1B – Jordan Jaffe (Jr) – U. of Richmond (27-32) – from Thousand Oaks, CA
2B – Henry Godbout (Jr) – U. of Virginia (32-18) – from Brooklyn, NY
SS – Noah Rabin* (Gr) – Florida Southern U. (38-15-1) – from Sebastopol, CA
3B – Ryan Zuckerman (Soph) – U. of Pittsburgh (28-27) – from Yardley, PA
C – Ethan Swidler (Jr) – Lafayette College (14-35) – from San Diego, CA
OF – Harrison Feinberg (Jr) – Northeastern U. (49-11) – from Greenwich, CT
OF – Ellis Schwartz (Sr) – George Washington U. (27-27) – from Cherry Hill, NJ
OF – Ethan Hott (Jr) – Stanford U. (27-25) – from Paradise Valley, AZ
OF – Sam Biller (Gr) – U. of Connecticut (38-21) – from Los Angeles, CA
*Noah Rabin plays for a D-2 school
PITCHERS
LHP – Adam Arther (Soph) – Kansas State U. (32-26) – from Altadena, CA
RHP – Dylan Banner (Jr) – SUNY Albany (22-32) – from Plainview, NY
RHP – Jack Ben-Shoshan (Sr) – Rice U. (17-40) – from Houston, TX
LHP – Ethan Firoved (Sr) – U. Pittsburgh (28-27) – from Virginia Beach, VA
RHP – Alex Kranzler (Soph) – Vanderbilt U. (43-18) – from Hackenack, NJ
LHP – Ryan Prager (Jr) – Texas A&M (30-25) – from Dallas, TX
RHP – Nate Stern (Fr) – Texas Christian U. (39-20) – from Los Angeles, CA
LHP – Jake Toporek (Sr) – Wagner College (31-22) – from Dana Point, CA
Detailed player statistics
POSITION PLAYERS
1B Jordan Jaffe (U. of Richmond) pieced together an outstanding season for the Spiders, batting .364 (#2 among teammates) on 79/217, clubbing 10 homers (#3), driving in 59 runs (#3), swiping 5/9 bases, cracking 19 doubles (#2 tie), and defending at .993 (398 putouts, 26 assists, 3 errors) while being named All-Atlantic 10 Conference, 1st-team.
Our classy second sacker, 2B Henry Godbout (U. of Virginia), batted .309 (#3 among teammates) on 59/191 for the Cavaliers, unloaded 8 dingers (#5), batted in 37 runs (#5), spanked 10 Ds (#4), stole 6/11 bags, and defended at .974 (66/123/5) while starting all 50 games. Henry was named All-ACC, 2nd team. The Red Sox picked him in Round 2C (#75 overall) of the 2025 MLB Draft.
With our team lacking a single full-time shortstop at the D-1 level, it provided us with the opportunity to include a superior D-II player, SS Noah Rabin of Florida Southern U. (38-15-1), who led the Moccasins with a .360 b.a. on 54/150, clouted 8 four-baggers, drove in 43 runs, swiped 12/14 bases, and posted a .620 slugging percentage. Noah was named All-Sunshine State Conference, 1st-team.
Holding court at the hot corner is 3B Ryan Zuckerman, who batted .295 (#4 among teammates) on 65/220 while leading the U. of Pittsburgh Panthers (28-27) with 13 home runs, 48 rbis, 18 Ds, and a .555 slugging percentage. Ryan will relocate to Georgia Tech for his junior year.
Working behind home plate is Leopards (14-35) receiver C Ethan Swidler (Lafafyette College), who batted .331 (#2 among teammates) on 59/178, posted 5 round-trippers (#3), drove in 33 runs (#3), and led his team with 14 Ds and a .494 slugging percentage while defending at .981 (365/38/8). Ethan was named All-Patriot League, 1st-team, and will play his senior year with the U. of Washington Huskies.
Our outfield begins with Harrison Feinberg (Northeastern U.), a junior from Greenwich, CT, who led the Huskies in hitting with a robust .367 b.a. on 76/207 with 18 round trippers (#1), 67 ribbies (#1), a .715 slugging percentage (#1), and 37/41 SBs (#1) while defending at 1.000% (107/2/0). Feinberg was named NCBWA (Writers) All-America, 1st-team, and ABCA/Rawlings All-America, 3rd-team.
Ellis Schwartz (George Washington U.) must be wondering: “What does a guy have to do to make all-conference?” Ellis led the Colonials in batting with a .346 b.a. on 72/208, homers with 9, rbis with 45, and slugging with .582, while collecting 16 Ds (#2) and fielding at .993 (139/1/1).
OF Ethan Hott (Stanford U.), a junior from Paradise Village, AZ, batted .342 (#2 among teammates) for the Cardinals on 40/117 to go with 3 homers, 25 rbis, 3/4 SBs and a 1.000 fielding percentage (83/1/0) while starting 35/39 games.
OF Sam Biller, a grad student at U. of Connecticut, recorded a .296 b.a. on 59/199, went yard 13 times (#3 among teammates), cashed in 60 runs (#3), rocked 14 Ds (#2), pilfered 26/29 bases (#2), and fielded at .980 (96/3/2) while starting 53/58 games.
STARTING PITCHERS
Our three-man starting rotation includes LHP Ryan Prager, a junior at Texas A&M (30-25) from Dallas, TX, who went 4-4 with a 4.21 ERA in 83.1 IPd (#1 among teammates) across 15 starts. Ryan was named the Southeast Conference Scholar-Athlete of the Year. The Guardians selected him in Round 9 (#282 overall) of the 2025 MLB Draft.
RHP Dylan Banner, a junior at SUNY Albany from Plainview, NY, closed at 5-5 with a fine 3.82 ERA in 94.1 IPd, walking 14 and fanning 68 along the way. Dylan was named All-America East Conference, 1st team.
LHP Jake Toporek, a senior at Wagner (31-22) from Dana Point, CA, put together an outstanding season, leading his team with an 8-1 record, 3.49 ERA, and 87.2 IPd across 14 starts and one relief appearance. Jake was named All-Northeast Conference, 1st-team.
LONG RELIEVERS
LHP Adam Arther (Kansas State U.), a sophomore from Altadena, CA, went 2-0 with a sparkling 2.45 ERA (#1 among teammates) in 25.2 IPd, making 20 relief appearances along with one start and earning one save.
RHP Alex Kranzler, a sophomore at Vanderbilt U. (43-18) from Hackensack, NJ, finished at 6-1 with a 3.62 ERA in 37.1 IPd, walked 7 batters, fanned 40, and earned 3 saves.
CLOSER
Our closer is LHP Ethan Firoved (U. of Pittsburgh), a senior from Virginia Beach, VA., who went 3-4 with a 3.86 ERA (#1 among teammates) in 23 relief appearances and tallied a team-leading 8 saves. Ethan was named All-Region, 2nd-team, by the American Baseball Coaches Association.
Want the freshest news about Jewish baseball players? Visit our Home Page. The Jewish Box Score updates in-game statistics of MLB players every 10 minutes. The rest of the Home Page is refreshed every week
You also can get selected updates via our Facebook, Twitter and Instagram pages
